print
Print
bookmark
Bookmark
x
ebook

Contact us

Our approach to managing work orders and assets are radically different from other CMMS products in the market.

x
ebook
x

$ 42 USD

PER USER PER MONTH

$ 35 USD

PER USER PER MONTH

SCHEDULE A DEMO

x

See Our Easy-to-Use Maintenance Management Software in Action

Start your 30-day free trial today!

see-our-easy-to-use-cmms-software-in-action

No credit card required | Start your 30 day FREE trial

image comparing additive manufacturing and traditional manufacturing

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Additive Manufacturing vs. Traditional Manufacturing - A Comprehensive Comparison

Share this page:

Introduction

Improving manufacturing processes has become critical to reducing costs, increasing production efficiency, and driving innovation. Across various industries, businesses continuously seek ways to simplify processes, enhance product quality, and meet consumer demands. Effective manufacturing plays a vital role in achieving these objectives, making the selection of the right manufacturing approach more important than ever. The purpose of this article is to provide a comprehensive comparison between two manufacturing processes: Traditional Manufacturing and Additive Manufacturing. By examining their strengths, limitations, and potential synergies, you will gain a deeper understanding of how each approach can be leveraged to meet specific production needs and how the integration of both methods can optimize manufacturing efficiency.

Streamline managing Work Orders, Preventive Maintenance, and Equipment.

Start your 30-day FREE trial

experience-streamlined-workflows

What is Traditional Manufacturing?

Traditional Manufacturing encompasses a range of subtractive processes where the material is systematically removed from a larger block or workpiece to create the desired final product. This approach has been foundational to industrial production for decades, involving several well-established techniques.

image showing traditional manufacturing

Common Techniques

Machining: 

This includes high-precision processes such as drilling, milling, and turning. While machining allows for detailed and accurate shaping, it often generates significant material waste as excess material is cut away to achieve the final form.

Injection Molding: 

Widely used for mass production, especially with thermoplastics, this technique involves injecting molten material into molds to form objects. It is highly efficient for creating large quantities of identical parts with consistent quality.

Forming: 

This process involves shaping heated materials into thin, hollow objects. It is commonly used in the production of packaging materials and other lightweight components.

Joining: 

This technique involves combining separate components through methods such as welding, fastening, or adhesive bonding. Good for assembling complex structures and achieving the desired final configurations.

These traditional manufacturing techniques have long been integral to the production industry, providing the precision, reliability, and scalability needed for various applications.

see-how-easy-click-maint-cmms-is

Streamline managing Work Orders, Preventive Maintenance, and Equipment.
See how easy Click Maint CMMS is.

BOOK A DEMO

 

What is Additive Manufacturing?

Additive Manufacturing (AM) is a transformative technology that creates objects layer by layer by adding material, commonly known as 3D printing. Unlike traditional manufacturing methods that subtract material from a solid block, AM constructs items from the ground up, enabling the creation of complex designs with minimal material waste. This approach not only allows for the production of complex geometries and internal structures but also offers significant material efficiency, as only the material necessary for the object is used.

image showing additive manufacturing

Common Techniques

Powder Bed Fusion (PBF): 

This technique involves melting powder materials using a laser or electron beam to fuse the powder particles into solid layers. It is widely used to create complex metal and plastic parts with high precision.

Material Extrusion: 

In this method, polymer material is extruded through a heated nozzle to build objects layer by layer. It is a popular technique for producing plastic prototypes and end-use parts.

Directed Energy Deposition (DED): 

This process uses focused energy, such as a laser or electron beam, to melt feedstock material, which is then deposited onto a substrate to build up the object. It is commonly used for repairing and adding material to existing components.

Sheet Lamination: 

This technique involves stacking and bonding thin sheets of material, which are then cut into the desired shape to create layered objects. It is suitable for producing large parts with relatively low resolution.

Binder Jetting: 

Binder jetting uses a binding agent to selectively bind powder materials, layer by layer, to form solid objects. It is known for its fast build speeds and ability to work with a variety of materials, including metals and ceramics.

Selective Laser Sintering (SLS): 

This process employs a high-power laser to sinter polymer particles into a solid form. It is valued for its ability to produce strong and durable parts with complex geometries.

Vat Photopolymerization: 

In Vat photopolymerization, a UV light cures liquid photopolymer resin, layer by layer, to create highly detailed and accurate objects. This method is often used for high-resolution prototypes and complex models.

These diverse techniques highlight the flexibility and precision of Additive Manufacturing, making it a versatile tool across various applications and industries.

Get your Click Maint CMMS estimate instantly!

estimate-instantly

Differences Between Traditional and Additive Manufacturing

image-showing-differences-between-traditional-and-additive-manufacturing

Aspect

Traditional Manufacturing

Additive Manufacturing

Physical Characteristics

Subtractive process (removes material from a workpiece). Strong, durable parts with established techniques.

Additive process (builds layer by layer). Parts can be strong but may not always match traditional methods in durability.

Production of Complex Geometries

Complex designs are constrained by Design for Manufacturing (DFM) rules, requiring simplification for manufacturability.

Freedom to create complex geometries, reducing the need for DFM rules. Supports complex shapes without the need for assembly.

Assemblies

Parts are typically manufactured separately and assembled afterward, requiring additional tools and time.

Can print assemblies as a single piece, reducing the need for post-production assembly and minimizing errors.

Sustainability

AM is more sustainable as it produces less material waste, using only the material required to build the part layer by layer. It also enables localized production, reducing transportation emissions.

Traditional manufacturing typically generates more waste through subtractive methods like machining and excess material use, especially in high-volume production. 

Custom Designs

Customization is limited due to tooling requirements and high costs. Producing unique designs can be expensive.

Allows for easy customization and unique designs at lower costs, making it ideal for one-off or small-batch production.

Manufacturing Equipment

Multiple tools and machines are required for different processes, such as milling, turning, drilling, and forming.

A single 3D printer can produce a wide range of parts, reducing the need for multiple machines or tools.

Material Selection

A broader range of materials is available, including metals, plastics, and composites, offering flexibility.

Limited material selection based on specific additive techniques (e.g., polymers, metals, or ceramics).

Production Quantity

Suited for high-volume production, making it cost-effective for mass manufacturing.

Best for low-volume production or custom parts. Costs rise significantly with high-volume runs due to time and material usage.

Lead Time and Production Costs

Longer lead times due to tooling, setup, and production processes. High cost for smaller production runs but becomes economical with scale.

Shorter lead times with quicker turnaround for small-batch or custom parts. Lower cost for short runs due to no tooling.

see-how-easy-click-maint-cmms-is

Streamline managing Work Orders, Preventive Maintenance, and Equipment.
See how easy Click Maint CMMS is.

BOOK A DEMO

 

How Additive Manufacturing Complements Traditional Manufacturing

Additive manufacturing (AM) offers several ways to complement traditional manufacturing, enhancing overall production efficiency and capabilities.

a graphical representation of how additive manufacturing complements traditional manufacturing

 

Fast Prototyping

Additive manufacturing significantly accelerates the prototyping phase of product development. Traditional manufacturing methods, such as machining or injection molding, often involve lengthy setup times and high costs for creating prototypes. In contrast, 3D printing enables rapid prototyping by producing parts directly from digital models without the need for specialized tooling. This speed allows design teams to quickly iterate on designs, test functionality, and make adjustments before committing to mass production. By reducing the time and expense associated with prototyping, AM helps companies reduce production times by up to 50%.

Enhanced Tooling

One of the significant advantages of AM is its ability to produce more complex and efficient tooling, such as injection molds with conformal cooling channels. These channels optimize the cooling process, reducing cycle times and improving the quality of final products. By integrating 3D printing into the tooling phase, manufacturers can achieve greater productivity and enhanced product performance, making it a valuable complement to traditional methods.

Flexible Manufacturing Capacity

Additive manufacturing provides exceptional flexibility in production capacity. Traditional manufacturing methods may require significant retooling or adjustments to scale production up or down based on demand. In contrast, additive techniques allow for scalable production without the need for extensive changes to equipment or processes. This flexibility is particularly valuable in industries where demand can fluctuate rapidly, such as aerospace or consumer goods. AM enables manufacturers to quickly adjust production volumes, making it possible to respond more effectively to market changes and customer needs.

Hybrid Processes

Combining additive and traditional manufacturing techniques, known as hybrid processes, can yield significant benefits. For instance, precision parts can be initially 3D-printed to create complex geometries, which are then refined through traditional machining processes. This hybrid approach leverages the strengths of both methods, the design freedom and material efficiency of AM, with the precision and finishing capabilities of traditional manufacturing. By integrating these processes, manufacturers can achieve high-quality components that meet any specifications while also benefiting from reduced production times and costs.

Additive manufacturing complements traditional manufacturing by enhancing prototyping speed, enabling part consolidation, providing flexible production capacity, and facilitating hybrid processes. By leveraging the strengths of both approaches, manufacturers can achieve greater efficiency, cost savings, and innovation in their production processes. 

Streamline managing Work Orders, Preventive Maintenance, and Equipment.

Start your 30-day FREE trial

experience-streamlined-workflows

Conclusion

Traditional and additive manufacturing each offer unique strengths; traditional methods excel in high-volume production and material variety, while additive manufacturing shines in rapid prototyping, complex geometries, and customization. Companies can maximize their production efficiency and flexibility by integrating both approaches. Utilizing traditional manufacturing for bulk production and additive techniques for prototyping and complex parts allows for a more adaptable and efficient manufacturing process. Embracing both technologies can drive innovation and operational excellence.

Book a Demo

close

Simplify Work Order Management

BOOK A DEMO

Refer and Earn $200

close

Know someone who can benefit from CMMS Software?

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Share with your peers:

x

x

BOOK A DEMO

Click Maint is a powerful, affordable CMMS that is easy to use and implement. Book a live demo!

Keep Reading

Definition and Brief History Additive Manufacturing (AM), commonly referred to as 3D ...

27 Sep 2024

Sustainability has become a key focus in modern manufacturing, with industries seeking ...

24 Sep 2024

In today's interconnected global economy, your supply chain is only as strong as its weakest ...

20 Sep 2024

In today's fast-paced manufacturing industry, your ability to collaborate effectively across ...

18 Sep 2024

In a rapidly evolving global landscape, supply chain collaboration is becoming a key ...

17 Sep 2024

In today's complex, interconnected business landscape, successful supply chain collaboration ...

13 Sep 2024

Introduction A Computerized Maintenance Management System (CMMS) plays a key role in ensuring ...

11 Sep 2024

Introduction Imagine a factory where everything runs smoothly, machines are well-maintained, ...

10 Sep 2024

Introduction Computerized Maintenance Management Systems (CMMS) have become essential tools, ...

6 Sep 2024

The choice of a Computerized Maintenance Management System (CMMS) can significantly impact ...

4 Sep 2024

A CMMS is a powerful maintenance management tool for modern maintenance operations, offering ...

3 Sep 2024

In the world of maintenance management, data reigns supreme. Did you know that organizations ...

30 Aug 2024

Whether you're a small business owner or a corporate bigwig, in the ever-evolving landscape ...

29 Aug 2024

Two notable contenders stand out in the realm of computerized maintenance management systems ...

28 Aug 2024

In field service, being efficient is super important. It's not just a big word people use. ...

27 Aug 2024

As you research and evaluate different Computerized Maintenance Management Systems (CMMS), ...

23 Aug 2024

Deciding on a Computerized Maintenance Management System (CMMS) for your organization, is an ...

22 Aug 2024

A Computerized Maintenance Management System (CMMS) is software that optimizes the way ...

21 Aug 2024

Introduction Most of us have experienced campus life either as students or visitors, and ...

20 Aug 2024

Imagine a guest arrives at your advertised cabin, only to find a leaky faucet, poor Wi-Fi and ...

16 Aug 2024